- Comments (179)
- Text Size: Down Up
moneysense.ca, 6/07/08
Review and Giveaway: The Intelligent Portfolio
![[Front Cover of The Intelligent Portfolio]](http://www.canadiancapitalist.com/images/books/intelligent_portfolio.jpg)
The Intelligent Portfolio does an excellent job of explaining ten basic concepts needed to make good investment decisions in a simple and straightforward manner. The book will be invaluable for a beginning investor and there is plenty to keep sophisticated investors interested as well. I found the discussion of market portfolio, which is composed of asset classes weighted by their proportion of total world market value and real return expectations derived by reverse optimization to be particularly interesting. The book has garnered rave reviews and I couldn’t do better than concurring with Peter L. Bernstein’s praise for the book:
Books on personal investing are a dime a dozen. But if we add them up, all those dimes come to plenty of money. This book is worth all that and lots more. With its strong foundation in theory, the depth of its insights, the power of its message, the clarity of its exposition, and the value of its examples, The Intelligent Portfolio is worth many multiples of anything else in this overcrowded field.
The author, Christopher L. Jones, works for Financial Engines, a firm that puts sophisticated techniques like Monte Carlo simulation, investment analysis and portfolio optimization in the hands of individual investors. The book includes a 1-year subscription to the Personal Online Advisor service from Financial Engines. The service allows you to do retirement planning but it seems to be of limited use for Canadian residents because data for Canadian bonds, mutual funds, tax rates, CPP and OAS are not available. The retirement planner is a nifty tool — if you input a savings rate, the current portfolio holdings, the retirement target date and the desired income in retirement, the planner runs Monte Carlo simulations and displays the probability of achieving the target through icons borrowed from weather forecasting. It would be wonderful if Financial Engines starts offering this service in Canada as well.
Book Giveaway: If you missed Million Dollar Journey’s giveaway of the book, here’s your second chance. The publisher has generously provided an extra copy for our readers. Participation is very simple — just leave a comment to this post and don’t forget to include your email address. Deadline for entries is Friday, July 11, 2008 at 8 p.m. EDT. One entry per person. Canadian residents only. Your email will not be shared with anyone. I’ll pick one entry at random after the deadline. Good luck!
moneysense.ca, 6/07/08









I really appreciate these reviews and the chance to win the book. Thanks!
Thanks.
Nice review. Please include me in the draw.
Thanks!
Always looking to expand my investment knowledge and really appreciate these book reviews.
You are right about PF books being a dime a dozen. My two favorites are The Wealthy Barber and Personal Finance for Canadians for Dummies. Both taught me a lot about basic personal financial principles. Thanks for the review.
I would like to be included in the draw.
Looks very worthwhile. Thanks.
Please include me in the draw.
Count me in!
Great review. Looks interesting. Count me in.
If I don’t win the book, I may have to break down and buy a copy.
Count me in!
Thanks in advance!
Thanks for the review.
This sounds like a book I should read!
Please include me!
Just getting into personal finance, would love the book – thanks.
Me too!
CC — Please count me in. It sounds like a worthwhile book for the library. Another good source, by the way, on building portfolios is Geoff Considine. One can browse his articles at:
http://seekingalpha.com/author/geoff-considine
Sounds like a good book.
Count me in for the draw!
I’d like to get my hands on that book!
Please count me in for the draw!
Please include me in the draw, cheers.
would be very interested in the book. count me in!
I guess ex-Canadian resident doesn’t count but good luck to everyone else!
Love to read! Enter me!
me too! thanks!
I’d like a shot at reading it, and the simulations sound like a good thing to get going. Might have to try that myself if I ever get nostalgic for Matlab or Maple…
Great site. And count me in for the draw
Count me in for the draw! Thanks
sounds like a great read!
Look forward to reading this book on my vacation.
Thanks.
Count me in!
I’m in.
Thanks for reviewing these. Count me in for the draw please.
I’d like in please…
please include me, thanks!
Count me in! Thanks!
Thank you for the opportunity!
Cheers,
Chris
Count me in!
me me me!
Count me in. Having a math background, I’m really interested in the analysis with Monte-Carlo.
I tries buying this book on the weekend but it was not available at my local bookstore. Count me in.
Thanks!
I’m in too, thanks CC.
Looks like a great read! Thanks!
Thanks.
Thank you! It will be a great addition to my library! Count me in.
Thanks!
Sounds like an interesting read. Sign me up.
I’d love to get my hands on this book. Count me in!
I just finished “The four pillars of investing” on your recomendation. Sounds like you like this one two. Where is this book on your top ten list?
this would be a great vacation read. Please include me in the draw.
Thanks,
Phil
Please include me in the draw.
Thanks,
- Suresh
Thanks!
Sounds like a very interesting read!
Please include me in the draw!
Count me in! Thanks.
Sounds interesting. Please add me to draw.
Please include me in the draw. Love your blog.
Sounds great!
Looks like an interesting read, please include me in the draw.
Please count me in!
Caount me in
I’m holding my breath.
Sounds like an interesting book. Good Review
Cheers,
Count me in, too!
I would love to read the book, too!
Soudns interesting – I’ll take a ballot!
Sounds like a good read, please include me!
Here’s my lot in for the draw.
Please add me to the draw
Count me in for the draw.
Great review. Please add me to the draw, hopefully as the winner
Looks like an excellent book. I’d also like to be included in the draw.
I would love to get this book for free
Keep up the great work on this blog! Sounds like a great book – count me in.
thanks for posting this, count me in for the draw.
Thanks!
I love your website and would like to enter the draw for the book (though I am bound to buy a copy regardless)
Thanks for the heads up about this book. Please enter me into the draw.
Sounds like an interesting read. Please count me in for the draw and thanks for pointing out the book.
I always enjoy your recommendations! Count me in.
the market portfolio you describe that includes reverse engineering returns is called the Black-Litterman approach which i believe was developed by a guy who of course worked for Goldman Sachs. It’s an interesting step forward on the tradition means of building a portfolio, which is usually descrbied as mean-variance optimization.
I’m in … free is the right price
Who couldn’t use a more intelligent portfolio?
I would love to read that book!
Thanks!
I’m in, thanks.
Please include me. Thank you.
Financial Engines was started by Nobel prize winner Sharpe!
Like the others I would like to be included in the draw. Also I like others have read The Wealthy Barber; pay yourself first.
Bring it on!!! Thanks.
Please enter me in the draw. Thanks for the giveaway!
Please include me in the draw.
Count me in!
Thanks for the review. Please include me in the draw.
Please include me in the draw. Love the website; fingers crossed!
My #1 blog
Thanks for the review and giveaway!
thanks for the review!!!
Thanks for the book suggestion!
Keep up the great work.
Always interesting read.
Thank you
I’m in!
Thanks,
Dan.
I’m in.
Sounds like a nice book to read!
)
Cheers,
Frog
As an independnet investor and the author of an investing book for Canadians, No Hype – The Straight Goods on Investing Your Money, I am always interested in reading new books on investing to test my investing ideas.
Sounds like a book I need to read!
Please include me in the book draw. Thanks for this great blog!
Count me in for the book draw. Thanks!
New to investing so I’d probably benefit from this book the most!
Sounds like a great book. Please include me in the draw.
Please include me. Thanks!
New to reading ‘so I’d probably benefit from this book the most!’
Cheers
Thanks.
Yay! Free book! =)
Please include me in the draw. Thanks!
Please include me! Thanks!
please include me, me, me!
Thanks!
Sounds like a good read. Please count me in.
Please count me in. Thanks!
Looks like a good book! Thanks
Count me in.
me me me pls
i wanna be a winner too!
Hey CC,
I am pretty skeptical about PF books, but, must admit am intrigued by your review. Count me in for the draw.
Thanks for the effort you put into your blog.
Thanks.
Thanks for doing this!
I’m in for the book draw.
Thanks!
Just finishing up The Intelligent Asset Allocator, this sounds like a good companion.
Thanks!
Please include me in the draw, thanks.
Please include me in the draw. Thanks.
Thanks for the review.
Sounds interesting I may have to check this book out if I don’t win.
I’d like to win!
Sounds like a great book.
I would love to win this!
Hope I win. Thanks.
Thanks for hte opportunity. I would love to read the book.
In for the draw. Thanks for the review!
Thanks for the great blog and chance to win a book!
Looking forward to learning more about my financial future.
Count me in!
DIY investor
Would love to win a copy, sounds good.
I’m game.
count me in! thanks
Sign me up
Sweet – great site by the way.
I feel lucky… Thanks!
Please count me in! Thanks.
As I’m currently reading the Intelligent Investor, this book would be a perfect way to implement Ben Graham’s ideas.. Hook me up!
Count me in!
Lauren, Edmonton AB
Book be mine.
Add me to the growing number of entrants…good luck to ME!
[...] version of the blog round up will return next week. Don’t forget to enter your name in the draw for one copy of The Intelligent Portfolio. Entries will be accepted until 8 P.M. EDT on Friday, July 11, 2008. Have a great [...]
Entry for Ryan:
“I would like to enter the contest for the Intelligent Portfolio book.”
John: While I liked the book and won’t hesitate to recommend it for reading, it won’t make my top ten list. It’s not the fault of the book, it’s very hard to bump some of the classics in my top ten list.
Please toss my name in the hat. Thanks!
Please count me in. Thanks!
Count me in!
Thanks for the excellent info on your site… & for a shot at the book!
Great website. Count me in for the giveaway!
I’d love to win the book! Lord knows I could use the help.
I’d like a chance to win the book also – looks helpful! Thanks!
Love to read it…
Nice review. Please include me in the draw.
I was just listening to the radio and heard them talking about how they got rid of the 40yr mortgage. I thought, hmmm, I’m sure CC must have some info on his site about that. Sure enough you did. You’re very timely! Good job!
Count me in for the draw!
Exactly the book I’m looking for! Please include me in the draw.
[...] Canadian Capitalist reviewed “The Intelligent Portfolio” and is having a Giveaway! You can still enter by 8pm EST Friday (just a few hours [...]
Thanks for entering me into the draw!
The contest is now closed. The winner will be announced shortly. Thanks to everyone for entering. I didn’t expect 170 entries or so. We’ll do another giveaway soon.
The winner picked at random through the random.org website is #17 — Tob.
Thanks for entering everyone. We’ll do another draw very soon. I didn’t expect so many entries, so the next time, I’ll make sure we have more to giveaway.
[...] you are a Canadian resident, Canadian Capitalist is giving away a free personal finance book so go check the post [...]
[...] Thanks to everyone who entered in The Intelligent Portfolio giveaway. The winner, picked at random, is [...]
Wow CC,
You got over 172 comments for this book giveaway. You must be pretty popular
Best Regards,
DGI
[...] Canadian bonds and was puzzled because one of the interesting ideas in The Intelligent Portfolio (Read Review) is the concept of a market portfolio, in which asset classes are held in proportion to their [...]
[...] The Intelligent Portfolio (Book Review), the author has published real expected returns from various asset classes calculated by Financial [...]
[...] Intelligent Portfolio (review), on the other hand, advises caution on REITs. The author, Christopher Jones, points out that stock [...]
[...] returns were much lower than we expected at the outset. In his book, The Intelligent Portfolio (review), Christopher Jones makes this point: Even for this conservative allocation [90% fixed income and [...]
Hi,
Would love to win this book! Thanks!
Barry