- Comments (12)
- Text Size: Down Up
moneysense.ca, 31/10/06
Penny Wise, Pound Foolish
As you can imagine, we are very careful about spending money. We clip coupons from the Sunday paper, buy necessities in bulk when they are on sale, brown bag our lunches, find ways to save on recurring expenses and avoid a daily latte habit. Sounds great, right? But then, I go out and buy a van that sat in our driveway most of the year.
The story begins last year. We already had a more-than-a-decade-old Honda Accord that I used to commute and my wife used to take the bus to work. When our twins were born, I bought a van (pre-owned, gently used, at a fair price) to ferry around the babies and their visiting grand parents. My wife was on parental leave for most of the past year and thinking back, we rarely used the van (mainly for visits to the paediatrician, we could have just as easily used the car). I can think of only a handful of times, when we actually needed the van.
I bring this up because I saw an ad for the same model van with similar mileage selling for $7,000 less than our purchase price in the local paper. Add in the insurance and oil changes, I figure that we had spent roughly $8,000 on a van parked in our driveway most of the year. In hindsight, I should have rented a van for the few times we really needed it and purchased one a year later, just before my wife went back to work.
Many personal finance books advise you to cut the small expenses to get ahead financially. While the little expenses left unchecked slowly drip away your savings, the big ones like automobiles and homes tend to drain it in an instant.
moneysense.ca, 31/10/06







Cars are huge money pits. There’s the cost of the car, gas, maintenance, insurance, parking, etc. At least with a house you can expect it to gain value, whereas most people are “upside down” on their cars as soon as they drive them off the lot. The freedom is worth it for a lot of people, but it comes at a steep price.
If you run the figures, it’s actually pretty sick about how much you can save by renting a second (or first) car whenever the need arises. Public transit has its own drawbacks, but, again, is much cheaper, and you end up with a hefty tax credit at the end of the year.
I ran into a similar situation with my wife when I moved earlier this year. Up to that point we always had the car and a company truck. Now with the new job not having a truck, she assumed I would want another car/truck.
I took one look at parking costs downtown and compared it to a bus pass. I could ride the bus fairly easily for half the price of just parking. So I didn’t get the second car and I’ve only run into a few times over the last six months where I would have liked one. I still have yet to run into a situation where I NEED one.
Don’t forget the medium size expenses ; especially any gadget from Future Shop, Costco or Ebay in my case
I’ve found that I don’t/can’t be bothered to watch the little expenses, however, I’m tenacious about the big stuff. Minimal Debt, no consumer debt and live within my means. I look at it like this: If I save $1,000.00 on mortgage interest through careful planning/negotiation that pays for a lot of little stuff. my 2 cents.
CC, I know what you mean, it’s discouraging when you get hit with large expenses after being so careful about the small stuff. JB makes a good point. My take is that I always take my monthly savings off my first paycheck of the month and if I have $10 left at the end of the month I am getting ahead. I prefer this to tracking pennies in a budget.
Re cars: I drive a car that almost got written off by my insurance company b/c I had a cracked windshield. I don’t know how better to describe the status of my vehicle.
Fantastic post.
I was just thinking about this notion to myself the other day — how often I meet people who religiously clip coupons from the paper, yet they happily blindly sign up for the first credit card or mortgage that somebody offers them.
The big stuff matters — you beat me to it. But I’ll probably still write on this.
I see a lot of people rushing out to a department store or grocery store daily/weekly for their whole life to buy some $30 items for $25…
Just think… if you can save $25,000 by getting a real estate deal, or $8,000 by getting a car deal (as the Canadian Capitalist said above) you can basically never worry about the price of general consumables for the rest of your life…
Saving $2 here and $10 there cutting coupons isn’t worth it once you factor in YOUR time. I’d rather invest lots of time and energy in getting a real estate, car or other “big” purchase deal. My house shopping time is like paying myself $500-$2000 per hour.
Loki: I did a get good deal on the automobile. Last year, the price was slightly less than fair value (I checked the price books at the library). My point is before making a big purchase, esp. a fast depreciating item like an automobile, I should ask myself if I really *need* it.
CC: the need vs. want debate is always going on in the back of my mind too. Do I really need a 50 inch Pioneer Elite Plasma Tv? Do I really need that Roast beef dinner at Hy’s? No and no.
True enough, cars are a complete waste of money, but most of us need one vehicle.
JB’s comment “If I save $1,000.00 on mortgage interest through careful planning/negotiation that pays for a lot of little stuff” is right absolutely correct. You have to watch and plan for the big ticket items. This is not for personal promotion, you can read my personal experience with mortgages and the advice here will save you Tens of $1,000’s and 5 to 7 years of your life. Read it here: http://www.mississauga4sale.com/Lock-In-Short-Term-Long-Term-Mortgage.htm#me
I like what Loki says about getting a good deal on a major ticket item, that is also the way to go. If you can save even $10k on your real estate purchase, amortized over 25 years, that’s a saving of about $23,000 Of course, if you follow my advice above, you will only have your mortgage for 17.3 years!
)
Excellent blog and information.
All the best,
Mark
Great thread and so true: big expenses are key to big savings…
Mark thanks for your input Jan 16th about mortgages. I checked out your story on your website – that’s a long, expensive life lesson. Nice that someone in a related, but independent field – real estate – can share insight without bias regarding mortgages. I like my mortgage rep but I never forget whose side she is on. I’m right there with you – short term or even open variable is hands down the way to go.
This thread relates so directly to my book I’ve just had published (Oct 06). I’m a first time author so, like the webmaster, my book has been a labour of love. I ended up calling it “Spend Smarter, Save Bigger: Finding BIG savings in your home, mortgage, vehicles, insurance and investments”. Anyway, sorry for the pitch but if you like this thread, try reading chapters one and two of my book on my website http://www.spendsmarter.ca (free download).
This is my first post – I hope to post more in the future and I believe CC will be reviewing my book at some point too.
Blessings,
Margot Bai
http://www.spendsmarter.ca
This is very true for so many families these days. It’s so easy to think we need the bigger items, and end up wasting money while we spend time clipping coupons for 33 cents off instead of paying attention to the big things
: -)
Good post!