Saving

ING Direct Lags the Competition

September 27, 2012

13 comments

In its early years ING Direct was a pioneer in the high-interest savings accounts space offering an interest rate that was far and away better than any of the banks. But for many years now, the best rates can be obtained not at ING Direct but at one of its new competitors.

Take high-interest savings accounts, for instance. ING Direct offers an interest rate of 1.35 percent on savings and RRSP accounts and 1.40 percent on TFSA accounts. But Ally, a competitor with CDIC coverage, offers a significantly better 1.80 percent on savings accounts. Peoples Trust, a small financial institution with no online access, offers 1.9 percent on savings accounts and a significantly better 3.0 percent on TFSA accounts. In fact, ING Direct’s interest rate on savings accounts is now so average that Canadians with discount broker accounts can get a comparable rate with high-interest savings accounts that are sold like mutual funds.

In an earlier post, I compared GIC rates available from ING Direct and Ally and found that Ally offers higher rates across every maturity and it remains true even today. Ally also offers a better rate for cashing out early compared to ING Direct. A quick check at TD Waterhouse shows that investors who can put up a higher initial investment of $5,000 can an interest rate that is 0.35 percent better for non-redeemable GICs at the discount broker.

This pattern can be observed in other products offered by ING Direct as well. Its THRiVE no-fee chequing account appears to be comparable to the competition. The Home Equity Line of Credit from ING Direct has an interest rate of 3.65 percent which even Royal Bank is able to beat with an interest rate of 3.5 percent.

While ING Direct may not offer the best rates anymore, it remains a leader in an important way. It offers a whole range of banking products in one place with better rates and lower fees than the big banks. The convenience factor of all accounts in one place is perhaps the reason why ING Direct, despite the competition, continues to remain very popular among cost conscious Canadians.

Should we care who owns ING Direct?

September 25, 2012

35 comments

Recently, Scotia Bank announced that it intends to purchase ING Direct Canada from its Dutch parent company ING Groep NV, which is divesting assets to repay billions of Euros in bailout money it received from the Dutch Government during the financial crisis. The sale has upset many ING Direct clients who had moved to the online bank attracted by high interest-rate savings products and a promise to charge no fees. News reports on the ING Direct sale attracted a flood of comments from clients who are worried that Scotia Bank might lower interest rates or institute service fees.

Such fears are understandable because it is not uncommon for the big banks to jack up fees after acquiring an erstwhile competitor. For instance, Scotia Bank acquired E*Trade Canada a few years back and online trading commissions for small accounts went from $19.99 to $24.99 and the high-interest rate Cash Optimizer accounts was scrapped entirely. TD Waterhouse’s acquisition of Ameritrade Canada offers yet another example: trading commissions on US stocks went from $10 to $29.

Scotia is making the right noises about the acquisition saying that it is “committed to preserving everything that ING Direct Canada’s customers have come to love about it”. One hopes that Scotia will maintain ING Direct’s high-interest savings, RRSP and TFSA accounts, high-interest GICs, no-fee chequing account, low-cost mutual funds and keep the existing no-fee structure. Offering clients access to Scotia’s banking machines would be an icing on the cake. As long as Scotia delivers on its commitment, customers will likely not care that ING Direct is owned by a big-five bank and ING Direct by any other name will sound just as nice.

Why isn’t Ally more popular?

November 29, 2011

40 comments

It is a mystery to me why Ally, which consistently offers better savings and GIC interest rates isn’t as popular as ING Direct. Take high-interest savings accounts: Ally has long offered a 2.0% interest rate compared to ING Direct’s 1.5%. And here’s how Ally’s GIC rates compare with ING Direct:

Ally ING Direct
1 Year 1.75% 2.00%*
2 Year 2.00% 1.60%
3 Year 2.25% 2.00%
4 Year 2.50% 2.25%
5 Year 2.75% 2.50%

* – Special “Cyber Monday” interest rate.

Now Ally’s product line-up is not as extensive as ING Direct’s (Ally does not offer RSP savings accounts, business savings accounts or chequing accounts) but as you can see from the table above, Ally’s GIC rates are consistently better than ING Direct’s. Even Ally’s early redemption rate is better: 1% compared to 0.5% at the big Orange. I have held savings accounts at both Ally and ING Direct and found little difference between the two – both offer much higher interest rates than the competition and typically do not charge any fees. One explanation for cool response to Ally may be its association with GMAC. However, Ally is a product of ResMor Trust Company which is member of Canadian Deposit Insurance Corporation. CDIC deposit insurance should provide peace of mind for savers worried about the financial health of Ally.