Among a handful of ETFs that Claymore Investments recently introduced is a dividend ETF: Claymore CDN Dividend and Income Achievers ETF (CDZ) that seeks to replicate Mergent’s Canadian Dividend and Income Achievers Index. Another dividend ETF that traded already on the TSX - iShares CDN Dividend Index Fund (XDV) - is based on the Dow Jones Canada Select Dividend Index.
I think that CDZ has a slight edge over XDV despite the fact that the MER is slightly higher and trading volume is lower. Both funds have almost half the portfolio in financials, but CDZ is better diversified with higher exposure to Industrials, Consumer Staples, Utilities and Energy and includes some income trusts and REITs.
The index methodology is also slightly different. The Dow Jones index is composed of stocks that have “consistently paid dividends” and the weights in the index is based on their proportionate dividend-per-share. The Mergent index, on the other hand, is made of stocks that have “consistently increased their annual dividends” and weighted based on yield. I think the Mergent version is slightly superior due to the emphasis on dividend growth.
| iShares CDN Dividend Index Fund | Claymore CDN Dividend and Income Achievers ETF | |
|---|---|---|
| Ticker | XDV | CDZ |
| Approx. Yield | 3.9% | 4.9% |
| Number of Securities | 30 | 57 |
| MER | 0.50% | 0.60% |
| Average Volume | 48,000 | 6,900 |
| Top Holdings | MBT, CM, RY, BMO, TD | ROC, EMA, CM, BMO, BNS |
Bookmark: del.icio.us Digg StumbleUpon
7 responses so far ↓
1 0xcc // Oct 23, 2006 at 8:11 am
That Claymore fund looks fairly attractive if it weren’t for ROC (Rothmans)although XDV also has Rothman’s but it only makes up 2.66% of the XDV and it makes up 5.33% of CDZ which I guess isn’t too much of a difference.
2 Guillaume // Oct 23, 2006 at 10:36 am
I’m a big fan on index funds, but I’m wondering in this case: why not buy TD Dividend Income instead? It’s 1,3,5,10 years avg returns are better than the group avg and the indexes. It seems to pursue more or less the same objectives as XDV and CDZ. It definitely beats their yields even when MER is taken into account.
What do you think? Am I missing anything in my analysis?
(note: I currently only hold XDV)
http://globefunddb.theglobeandmail.com/gishome/plsql/gis.fund_pro?fundname=TD+Dividend+Income&pi_universe=PUBLIC_FUND&product_id=
3 Canadian Capitalist // Oct 23, 2006 at 10:56 am
I avoid mutual funds entirely with the exception of index funds and some ultra-low cost funds. TD Dividend Income reports 10-year returns of 11.8%, whereas CDZ’s over the same term is 17.7%. Would it continue to outperform going forward? I don’t know but I do know for sure it will be much cheaper to own, so I would place my bets on the ETF instead.
4 farron // Oct 23, 2006 at 11:03 am
that’s so funny. I was just about to add this etf to my rrsp.
5 MikeB // Oct 23, 2006 at 4:51 pm
Both of these ETF’s may be better suited for investment outside of the RRSP. Dividends are best earned outside the tax shelter.
6 growth in value // Oct 24, 2006 at 11:20 am
Thanks for your insights, CC. I only need one more pay period to have amassed enough cash to jump into a new equity, and I was thinking (after having done my own research) of buying CDZ for it’s dividend focus, and the fact that I think it’s a good defensive holding.
Plus it gives me good exposure to the financial sector — I must be the only Canadian investor who doesn’t have any oil or financials in my portfolio yet!!!
The fact that you seem to like it too is another plus in my book.
Oh and as for this: MikeB Says: Dividends are best earned outside the tax shelter.
Here we go again….
I’ll be putting my CDZ outside my RRSP but as always, I’m interested in viewpoints for and against. I’m in the middle tax bracket.
7 JShah // Nov 14, 2006 at 10:52 pm
Are people of the same view for CDZ after tax changes for income trust ? i.e. is XDV now more preferable?
Leave a Comment