Mr. Garth Turner, self-described “Canada’s foremost personal finance source” and recently minted Tory Member of Parliament, is seeking input from middle-class Canadians on what they would like to see in the upcoming Federal Budget. He mentions a few ideas, some of which were proposed in earlier election platforms. Here is my wish list for the Federal Budget:
- Keep the Liberal Income Tax Cuts: If there is one thing that is certain to be in the budget, it is the plan to cut the GST by 1%. During the 2004 Federal Election, the Tories proposed a plan to eliminate the 22% tax bracket for incomes between $35K-$70K, which I think is a much better idea. Such a significant 6% cut in taxes will immensely benefit middle-income Canadians. In principle, taxing consumption is better than taxing income (with some exceptions).
- Registered Lifetime Savings Plan: Low-income Canadians do not have a tax-advantaged savings vehicle. A savings plan to which contributions are made after-tax but withdrawals are tax-free would be a splendid idea.
- No Mortgage Interest Deductibility: Tax-deductible mortgage interest just means that house prices will increase to reflect the effective lower interest rate. To offset this break, capital gains exemption on personal residence will likely be eliminated. Why rob Peter to pay Paul?
- Hybrid Vehicle Credit: A tax credit that offsets some of the higher outlay involved in the purchase of a hybrid vehicle would be a splendid idea. The credit would save Canadians money and help reduce greenhouse emissions.
Be sure to send your thoughts and opinions to Mr. Turner. His contact information can be found here.
Bookmark: del.icio.us Digg StumbleUpon
3 responses so far ↓
1 0xcc // Feb 23, 2006 at 6:49 am
I totally agree with these points.
I personally would like to see some sort of combination of a GST cut and income tax cut. Even if it is something like removing the GST on some items that a significant portion of people need (for example, diapers although I’m not sure if GST applies to those) or even increasing the GST credit for lower-income people.
The mortgage interest deductibility is a little bit of a funny one. There currently is a wealthy/non-wealthy divide with respect to mortgage interest deductions. If you are well-off enough to have non-registered investments that have a market value that is equal to or higher than your mortgage you can do a ’swap’. Sell off all your investments, pay off your mortgage, take a loan using your house as collateral and then invest the money you get from that loan. Bingo, your mortgage interest is tax-deductible
2 Canadian Capitalist // Feb 23, 2006 at 9:06 pm
You are right that wealthy folks are able to borrow money to invest and generate a tax break. But the key point is very few are able to take advantage of this. If everyone is allowed a mortgage deduction, asset prices will inflate to reflect the lower carrying costs. And eliminating the capital gains exemption would be unfair to people who have already paid off their mortgage.
3 GIV // Feb 24, 2006 at 6:51 pm
Accountability in government!
Thanks for the link, and check out my blog
Leave a Comment